Summary:
Bhagavad Gita, Chapter 4, Verses 1-2: Knowledge originates from Īśvara, not human intellect – humans only discover what already exists through observation. The first person to see any truth is called a ṛṣi, and after that no second ṛṣi is needed because truth remains consistent. This shows three elements are needed for any knowledge to manifest: Source (Īśvara), first observer (ṛṣi), and tradition (paramparā), showing no original human author. Unlike other teachings requiring blind faith, Krishna's knowledge presents what you must recognize – “you are Brahman” is a verifiable fact. Because ātmā is eternal, knowledge of ātmā is equally eternal, making this an imperishable yoga/knowledge (avyayam yogam). However, this knowledge becomes “lost” when it reaches scattered minds, and misinterpretations then get passed from teachers to students.
Additionally, to receive the knowledge, you must first recognize a problem in your life, else the solution remains meaningless. For instance, Arjuna had opportunities to learn this knowledge earlier, but he was busy acquiring princely skills instead. Only in the battlefield, when reality shattered his cherished notions, did real questions arise – contributed by his viveka (discrimination) and life of dharma.
Summary of Bhagavad Gita, Chapter 1-3
Chapter 1 – The Context and Crisis
STAGE 1: Bubble of expectations popped by the real-world – leading to despair
Arjuna, who had previously only been interested in regaining his kingdom and settling accounts with his enemies, found himself in despair/disappointment on the battlefield.
His life of dharma and inquiry (viveka) had given him the clarity to recognize the need for deeper knowledge.
STAGE 2: Seeking for solution
Faced with this crisis, Arjuna asked two fundamental questions: What should I do in this situation, and how do I gain existential fulfillment?
He declared himself Krishna’s disciple and asked to be taught about the ultimate good.
STAGE 3: Seduced by the easy way out
He also said he would prefer to live the life of a bhiksu who lives on alms (2.5) – meaning he was thinking of a life of sannyasa, wanting to renounce everything and seek moksa.
This created the perfect opportunity for Krishna to begin his teaching.
So Chapter 1 shows the universal human journey: Expectations based on our immaturity and ignorance > Disappointment when figure out you haven't figured out life > Focus on solution > Resist the easy way out > Seek Support
Chapter 2 – Krishna’s Teaching Strategy
Krishna tells Arjuna to man-up!
Krishna first tried to arouse Arjuna’s enthusiasm, calling his despair unbecoming (2.2: “…from where has this despair come upon you? It is unbecoming of an upright man”) and telling him not to yield to unmanliness (2.3: “Do not yield to unmanliness. This does not befit you… Give up this lowly weakness of heart and get up”)
Arjuna justifies his despondency
However, Arjuna continued to explain why he could not fight [he felt it would be sinful to kill his teachers, relatives, and respected elders].
Krishna gives larger perspective
Only then did Krishna shift his approach, beginning with profound statements like “You grieve for those who should not be grieved for, even though you speak words of wisdom” (2.11) and “the unreal never is and the real is never absent” (2.16).
So Krishna’s strategy was to start with the nature of the Self, knowing which gives existential fulfillment and puts situational challenges in proper perspective, so that one is not constantly bothered by the question “what’s the highest purpose of life?”
Krishna show Karma-Yoga lifestyle
Krishna also explained Karma-Yoga, a lifestyle that helps us live with freedom from the grip of likes-and-dislikes (which constitute binding desires) that pressure us into situations that create mini-dramas, add unnecessary complexity, unpredictability, and anxiety. But also helps purify the thinking instrument so we're more lucid what is to be done, and capable of recognizing the true self.
Arjuna asks about jñāni (enlightened person)
Arjuna asked, 2.54: “What is the description of a person of firm wisdom, one whose mind abides in the self? How does such a person… speak, sit, and walk?”
Krishna described such a person is who:
-
- Gives up all desires arising in the mind [refers to binding desires; not functional desires like hunger, reaching out to help] and is happy in oneself with oneself alone (2.55)
- Is unaffected by adversities (unpleasant situations) because free from longing, fear and anger – thus friendly towards situations which bring harmony (2.56)
- Neither over-rejoicing in pleasant nor hating unpleasant experiences – as doesn't give either excess meaning to things (2.57).
- A wise person is like a full ocean that remains unchanged whether rivers enter it or not (2.70), completely unaffected by what flows in or out.
Imagining too long how an object will improve my life, leads to a binding-desire (“I must have it!”)
Krishna also explained how dwelling on objects creates false value, leading to attachment, then desire, anger, delusion, loss of memory, incapacitation of mind, and ultimately destruction (2.62-63).
He concluded that being established in Brahman cannot be lost once gained, even if attained at the very end of one’s life (2.72).
Chapter 3 – Arjuna’s Objection and Krishna’s Clarification on Action
Arjuna raised a crucial objection, asking why Krishna was impelling him into gruesome action if knowledge is superior to action (3.1: “If in your contention knowledge is better than action, why then do you impel me into this gruesome action?”).
Krishna clarified that there are two valid committed lifestyles (3.3): “the pursuit of knowledge for the renunciates and the pursuit of karma-yoga for those who pursue activity”. In Arjuna's case, due to his position in life and nature, action was the best choice.
Krishna explained that we accumulate unhealthy patterns and stories that cloud the mind, which need to be undone through a life of karma-yoga.
Karma-Yoga comes from the omniscient Lord, thus it can't fail to help you
Karma Yoga is not the suggestion of a biased person, but comes from the omniscient Lord who knows everything in detail, and has observed human struggle since time immemorial. Thus it's effectiveness is eternal and the best possible way to live.
Additionally, he explained that no one can remain without action even for a moment (3.5: “no one ever remains for even a second without performing action because everyone is forced to perform action by the three gunas born of prakrti”).
Krishna taught that karma-yoga consists of two essential components:
- Samanya-dharma – universal ethical principles where one asks “Is this fair to everyone?”. Living responsibly, doing the right thing even if you won't be recognized. You're not outside Ishvara's order, thus it's the only way to remain in harmony.
- Svadharma – recognizing that (a) you are placed in a unique situation with specific people to whom you have responsibilities, and (b) acting according to your unique talents and strengths. Krishna further emphasized importance of following one’s own dharma rather than another’s (3.35: “Better is one’s own imperfectly performed dharma than the well performed dharma of another… The dharma of another is fraught with fear”)
Two enemies that create disturbances in life:
Arjuna asked what forces people to do wrong despite knowing better (3.36: “Impelled by what, does a person commit sin… even though not desiring to?”). Krishna explained that [binding] desire and anger born of rajas are the real enemies (3.37: “This desire, this anger, born of the guna rajas, is a glutton and a great sinner. Know that to be the enemy”).
Bhagavad Gita, Chapter 4, Verse 1-2:
Nature and Origin of Self-Knowledge
श्रीभगवान् उवाच
इमम् विवस्वते योगम् प्रोक्तवान् अहम् अव्ययम् ।
विवस्वान् मनवे प्राह मनुः इक्ष्वाकवे अब्रवीत् ॥ ४-१॥
śrībhagavān uvāca
imam vivasvate yogam proktavān aham avyayam ।
vivasvān manave prāha manuḥ ikṣvākave abravīt ॥ 4-1॥
एवम् परम्परा-प्राप्तम् इमम् राजर्षयः विदुः ।
सः कालेन इह महता योगः नष्टः परन्तप ॥ ४-२॥
evam paramparā-prāptam imam rājarṣayaḥ viduḥ ।
saḥ kālena iha mahatā yogaḥ naṣṭaḥ parantapa ॥ 4-2॥
Śrī Bhagavān said: I taught this imperishable yoga to Vivasvān, Vivasvān taught it to Manu, (and) Manu taught it to Ikṣvāku. Handed down from generation to generation in this way, the kings who were sages knew it. (But) with the long lapse of time, Arjuna, the scorcher of foes! this yoga has declined in the world.
The Nature and Origin of Self-Knowledge: “I taught this yoga to Vivasvan, who taught to Manu, who taught to Ikshvaku. Handed down generation to generation”
Knowledge Comes from the Source, Not Human Creation
Kṛṣṇa establishes that this knowledge originates from Īśvara alone, not from any individual intellect or speculation.
Every knowledge has its being in Īśvara, and humans through observation come to know it. Just as gravity existed before Newton observed why apples fall down rather than up, this self-knowledge existed before the first observer recognized it. The first person who sees any truth is called a ṛṣi. From that point forward, you don’t need a second ṛṣi because the observation will be exactly the same – truth remains predictable and consistent.
For any knowledge to manifest, three elements are involved: Source (Īśvara), first observer (ṛṣi), and passing it on (tradition). This shows there’s no original human author, and understanding this invokes humility.
A Living Tradition Preserves Verifiable Truth
Kṛṣṇa’s knowledge differs from other revealed teachings because it presents something you must recognize rather than believe. While other revelations require faith in promises about afterlife, the statement “you are Brahman” presents a verifiable fact, like “water boils at 100° Centigrade at atmospheric pressure.”
Why This Knowledge Never Dies: “I taught this imperishable yoga (knowledge)” (vivasvate yogam)
The phrase “imperishable yoga” can refer to two things…
- Imperishable yoga in reference to Pramana for pointing out the Self: Knowledge of self is eternal, unborn, and changeless. Once you gain this knowledge, you gain it forever. In short, if ātmā is eternal, then knowledge or pramana revealing ātmā is equally eternal. Unlike experiences such as nirvikalpa-samādhi from which you return, this knowledge destroys the notion of being a limited individual (jīvatva).
- Imperishable yoga in reference to eternal principles within creation: No knowledge is ever new – it is always ancient (purātana). For instance – circle, heat, echo, light – are eternal principles. Whatever you discover always existed, just as the earth always traveled around the sun whether humans knew it or not.
Why Knowledge Appears Lost and Contaminated: “this yoga has declined in the word”
The knowledge becomes “lost” not because it disappears, but because it reaches people whose minds are scattered, whose attention is fragmented. Additionally, people were busy with many things, and the Duryodhanas of the world were too numerous, leaving no time for this knowledge, thus shallow interpretations were passed on.
Additionally, any subtle knowledge is subject to misinterpretation, forming divisions of interpretations. Misinterpretations get passed onto students who become teachers, perpetuating errors through generations. This is why it’s better to listen to Vedanta without background notions from other schools.
The Qualification for Receiving Knowledge: “handed down from generation to generation”
The Necessity of Recognition and Asking
Unless you recognize that there is a fundamental problem, offering a solution proves useless. You can receive hints that a problem exists, but only when you recognize the problem (and that it directly affects you), does the solution become meaningful.
Arjuna had opportunities to hear this knowledge during his upbringing when sages walked in and out of the palaces. However, as a prince, he was concerned with acquiring princely skills and accomplishments. Even during twelve years of exile, his focus was acquiring missiles and skills to win back the kingdom.
When Readiness Appears
Only in the battlefield, when Arjuna saw reality as it is, popping Arjuna’s dearly held imagination, did the right questions arise. What summon the right questions was Arjuna having lived a life of dharma with proper viveka (discrimination between right and wrong). Otherwise he would’ve been fine with destruction, in which case he wouldn’t need Krishna, in which case he wouldn’t have been taught knowledge that liberates.
Then he asked Krishna for the solution, the opinion of someone objective who is not personally entangled in the circumstance.
NEXT VERSE: Reason why Krishna is sharing this same knowledge to Arjuna…
—
Course was based on Swami Dayananda (Arsha Vidya) home study course.
Recorded 2 Nov, 2025