Lesson 69: Sanskrit for Beginners Course: Optative, Perfect, Interrogative, Indefinite

Summary:

Covers Perfect (used interchangeably with Imperfect), Interrogative Pronouns (EG: Which? With whom?) and Optative (used interchangeably with Imperative).

Source: Introduction to Sanskrit (4th Ed) – Thomas Egenes – Part Two


Session deals with: VOL2, L26, PG 156-171

Perfect:  (liṭ लिट्)

  • ABOUT:
    • It's Past tense.
    • Same as Imperfect, but not witnessed by the speaker.
    • In practice, used interchangeably with Imperfect.  Since Imperfect is easier, stick with it.
    • EG: Rāma went to the forest.  >  rāmaḥ vanam jagāma  रामः वनम् जगाम
  • Construction Formula:
Parasmaipada (Active) :  √tud तुद् 6U  (to push)
  Single: Dual: Plural:
3rd tutoda         तुतोद
He/she pushed
tutudatuḥ    तुतुदतुः tutuduḥ    तुतुदुः
2nd tutoditha    तुतोदिथ
You pushed
tutudathuḥ  तुतुदथुः tutuda      तुतुद
1st tutoda         तुतोद
I pushed
tutudiva        तुतुदिव tutudima  तुतुदिम
Parasmaipada (Active) :  √ni नी  1P  (to lead)
  Single:
STEM:
ninay निनय् or nināy निनाय्

Dual:
STEM:
ninī  निनी
Plural:
STEM:
ninī  निनी
3rd nināya         निनाय ninyatuḥ     निन्यतुः
Why ny?  nī  +  a__ = ny
ninyuḥ    निन्युः
2nd ninayitha    निनयिथ   or
Why nāy, and not nai?
  If you know, comment below.    

ninetha       निनेथ
nī  > guṇa = ne

ninyathuḥ   निन्यथुः ninya       निन्य
1st ninaya        निनय       or

nināya        निनाय
ninyiva        निन्यिव ninyima  निन्यिम
      • More examples? See Vol2, PG159-161.
  • Rules:
    • RULE 1: Parasmaipada Perfect & Ātmanepada Perfect are constructed differently:
      1. Parasmaipada Root Changes:
        1. Single:
          • Rule A:
            1. If root's vowel is SHORT and it's BETWEEN 2 consonants, then vowel takes guṇa in all three persons:
              • EG:
                • √viś √विश्  6P (to enter)     >   viveś विवेश्
                • √druh √द्रुह्  4P (to hurt)     >   dudroh दुद्रोह्
                • √kṛt √कृत्  6P (to cut)          >   cakart चकर्त्.
            2. Any other combination:
              • 3rd single:   Final vowel in root, takes: vṛddhi.
              • 2nd single:  Final vowel in root, takes: guṇa.
              • 1st single:    Final vowel in root, takes either: guṇa or vṛddhi.
              • EG: √kṛ √कृ 8U (to do)
                • 3rd single:   cakāra चकार
                • 2nd single:  cakara चकर
                • 1st single:   cakara चकर   or   cakāra चकार
          • Rule B:
            • a अ before a single final consonant in the root, also follows Rule 1 above.
            • EG:  √tap तप्   1P  (to heat)
              • 3rd single:    tatāp  तताप्
              • 2nd single:   tatap  ततप्
              • 1st single:     tatap  ततप्   or  tatāp तताप्
        2. Dual/Plural:
          • Leave root alone (meaning don't make any changes to root). But there is ONE exception. See Rule below…
          • Rule Where Root Changes in Dual/Plural:
            • If root: (a) begins with following unaspirated letters: ka क, ca च, ja ज, ṭa ट, ḍa ड, ta त, da द, pa प, ba ब — and  (b) whose a अ is right before a single final consonant in the root — then apply these 2 conditions:
              1. Root will NOT undergo reduplication.
              2. Simply change the root's a अ  with e ए  +  attach ending.
            • EG: 
              • √day √दय् 1Ā (to impart):
                • 3rd dual:    deyāte      देयाते
                • 2nd dual:   deyāthe   देयाथे
                • 1st  dual:   deyivahe  देयिवहे     
              • √paṭh पठ् 1P (to read):
                • 3rd pl:   peṭhuḥ      पेठुः
                • 2nd pl:  peṭha         पेठ
                • 1st pl:   peṭhima    पेठिम
            • Case where rule doesn't apply: √phaṇ फण् 1P (to go) — because pha फ  is aspirated.
      2. Ātmanepada Root Changes:
        • Single / Dual / Plural: Leave root alone (meaning don't make any changes to root). Just reduplication + √root + ending.
    • RULE 2:
      • Endings which begin with a consonant [as seen in Garden PG4 (61, 62)] — are often joined to STEM with i इ. Doesn't apply to all roots.
        • Exception: Four roots ending in ṛ ऋ that DO NOT take i इ in the first persons dual & plural:
          √kṛ कृ 8U (make), √bhṛ भृ 1U (bear), √sṛ सृ 1P (go), √vṛ वृ 5U (choose).

 

  • REDUPLICATION RULES WHICH ONLY APPLY WHEN CONSTRUCTING ‘PERFECT':
  Rule: Example:
1. Roots beginning with a consonant, the a, ā, ṛ  अ आ ऋ — will always reduplicate with a अ. Never with i इ, as sometimes seen in Verb 3 present construction.  √pṛ  पृ  3P (to protect)      >  piparti       पिपर्ति    (He protects)     
* Present
√pṛ  पृ  3P (to protect)      >  papartha   पपर्थ      (You protected)   
* Perfect
      

√mā मा 3Ā (to measure)  >  mimīte       मिमीते    (He measures)
* Present
√mā मा 3Ā (to measure)  >  mamatuḥ   ममतुः    (Those two measured)
* Perfect

2. A root with initial a अ before a single final consonant, repeats. Thus changes to ā आ. √ad अद्  2P (to eat)              >    āda         आद   (He ate)      

√aj  अज्  1P (to go)               >    āja          आज   (He went)

√amb अम्ब्  1P (to sound)   >    anamba अनम्ब  (He sounded).
* Notice doubling doesn't apply here, since m म् is not final consonant in root.

3.
  • For Singular: 
    • Root with initial i इ, changes to e ए. Reduplicated portion will be: iy इय्
    • Root with initial ū ऊ, changes to o ओ. Reduplicated portion will be: uvo उवो.
  • For Dual & Plural:
    • Root with initial i इ, changes to ī ई.
    • Root with initial u उ, changes to ū ऊ.
  • √iṣ इष्  6P (to desire)
    • Single:             iyeṣa    इयेष      (He desired)    
      • i + eṣ = iyeṣ    इ + एष् = इयेष्
      • Explanation how we got to iyeṣ इयेष् : 
        • Step 1 (root): Increase iṣ इष् to guna = eṣ एष्
        • Step 2 (redup): Initial i इ remains + joins corresponding semi-vowel y य्  [as seen in  Garden PG2 (30)].
    • Dual/Plural:   īṣatuh  ईषतुह्   (Those two desired)  
      • i + iṣ = īṣ     इ + इष् = ईष्
  • √uc उच्  4P (to fit)
    • Single:            uvoca  उवोच      (He fitted)
      • u + oc = uvoc    उ + ओच् = उवोच्
    • Dual/Plural:  ūcatuḥ  ऊचतुः    (Those two fitted)
      • u + uc = ūc        उ + उच् = ऊच् 
4. Roots that begin with long vowels: ā आ, ī ई, ū ऊ, o ओ, e ए  — do not undergo reduplication. Just add the ending. √ās  आस् 2Ā (to sit)      >   āse    आसे   (He sat)
√īj    ईज्   1P (to go)      >   īja      ईज     (He went)
√ūy  ऊय्  1Ā (to sew)   >   ūya   ऊय    (He sewed)

Interrogative vs. Indefinite vs. Negative Indefinite:

Before we go into theory below, look at this table for example:

Interrogative Pronouns:

  • How to form a question word?
    • Step 1: First have open [Garden PG4 (37-39)].
    • Step 2: Replace first letter with k क्.  
      • Exception: Neuter, Sing (Nom & Acc) = kim किम्
      • EG: tasmāt तस्मात्  (from him)  >  kasmāt कस्मात्  (From who/whom/which?)
  • Examples:
    • (kayā naukayā) rāmaḥ vanam agacchat  (कया नौकया) रामः वनम् अगच्छत्  :  (With which boat) Rāma went to the forest?
    • kaḥ jalam pibati  कः जलम् पिबति                                   :  Who drinks the water?
    • kiṃ te kṛṣṇaṃ vanaṃ jānanti  किं ते कृष्णं वनं जानन्ति   :  What do they know about the black forest?
    • kā sthitaprajñasya bhāṣā  का स्थितप्रज्ञस्य भाषा            :  What is the sign of (one whose intellect is steady)?

Indefinite Pronouns:

  • What is it?
    • Vague indicator about what/who it's referring to.
    • It's basically, interrogative + words like some/any/ever.  EG: Somehow, anywhere, whatever.
  • CONSTRUCTION FORMULA:
    • Method 1:
      • kaḥ/kā/kim कः / का / किम्   +   api/cana/cid अपि / चन / चिद्   =   Indefinite Pronoun
      • EG:
        • kaścana               कश्चन                   : somebody/anyone.
        • kiṃcana/kiṃcit   किंचन / किंचित्    : anything.
        • kenacit                केनचित्                : with anything/someone. (Whatever/whoever).
        • kenāpi                 केनापि                  : with anyone.
        • kaścit jalam apibat  कश्चित् जलम् अपिबत्                               :  Someone drank the water.
        • udyāne (kecana vṛkṣāḥ) santi  उद्याने (केचन वृक्षाः) सन्ति       : There are (some trees) in the garden.
    • Method 2:
      • Repeat the pronoun. Words will always begin with y य्.
      • EG:
        • yat yat       यत् यत्         : whatever.
        • yada yada यद यद         : whenever.
  • How to negate an indefinite pronoun?
    • Add na न before.  EG:
      • na kaścana / kaścit       न कश्चन / कश्चित्            : nobody/noone.
      • na kiṃcana / kiṃcit       न किंचन / किंचित्         : nothing.
      • na kaścit jalam apibat  न कश्चित् जलम् अपिबत्  :  Noone drank the water.

Optative / Potential:  (liṅ लिङ्)

  • ABOUT:
    • It's Present tense.
    • Used to express a wish. What “SHOULD / MIGHT” be done.
    • Also used in context of: a gentle order (less forceful then Imperative), advice, expectation.
    • When in doubt: Use it interchangeably with Imperative.
  • Construction Formula:
  • Sentence examples:
Rāma should obtain Sītā. ramaḥ sītam labheta
रमः सीतम् लभेत
These boys might/should play in the pond. bālāḥ vāpyām dīvyeyuḥ
बालाः वाप्याम् दीव्येयुः
With whom should I walk to my house? kena mama gṛham vrajeyam
केन मम गृहम् व्रजेयम्
What should I say to my mom? kim mama mātām vadeyam
किम् मम माताम् वदेयम्

Homework:

  • STEP 1:
  • STEP 2:
    • Grasp theory of Perfect. Then see in Vol2, PG159-161 more examples.
  • STEP 3:
  • STEP 4:
    • Grasp theory of Optative on this page. Then see in Vol2, PG166-170 more examples.
  • STEP 5:
    • PG171: Go over the new vocabulary.
  • STEP 6:
    • PG172-175: Do all exercises.
  • STEP 7:
    • PG150: Attempt to translate the verse.
      1. Break down sandhi.
      2. Write English definition top of each word.
      3. Translate.
      4. Compare your translation to author's.
  • STEP 8:
    • PG152-155: Go over theory at your own time. Not important, unless aiming for Sanskrit scholar.

Questions:

You'll have more questions throughout the course. How to ask? Leave in comments below, so others can also benefit. We'll respond within 48 hours. Only ask specific to this Lesson.

 

—

Recorded 12 June, 2022

 

2 Comments

  1. What are the interrogative pronouns to use for stems mad, asmad, tvad, and yusmad? I read pages 162 – 164 in volume 2 (Thomas Egenes) which explains declining kah like the stem “tad”.

    Thank you

    1. Here, on pg 3 (#37, 38, 39): https://yesvedanta.s3.amazonaws.com/sanskrit/Sanskrit-Garden-IAST.pdf

      For example for #37 (He/That), just replace the first letter, with “k”.

      EG:
      a) Saḥ = He. Kaḥ = Who/what/which?
      b) saḥ kaḥ = Who/what is he?
      c) tau kau = Who/what are they? (dual)

      ================
      mad, asmad
      ================

      [1] What? kaḥ-kā.
      EG: Man says, “What am I?” > aham kaḥ asmi? | Woman: aham kā asmi?

      [2] Where? kutra, kva (ind)
      EG: Mas/Fem: “Where am I?” > aham kutra asmi?

      Same as for [2] above…
      [3] How many/much? kiyat (ind)
      [4] When? kadā (ind)
      [5] How? katham (ind)

      ================
      tvad, and yusmad?
      ================

      Use #37 from above PDF when “you” refers to masculine, and #38 when “you” refers to feminine.

      EG:
      a) Who are you (man)? = tvam kaḥ asi? | Woman: tvam kā asi?
      b) From what/which world are you (mas) from? = kasmāt (abl) lokāt (abl) tvam asi? (See #37 ABL)
      b) From what/which world are you (fem) from? = kasyāḥ (abl) lokāt (abl) tvam asi? (See #38 ABL)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *