Summary:
Lesson 120 shows properties about the 5 levels of error the “I” identifies with. Causal Body. Logic of rebirth. Sanchita Karma. Prarabdha Karma. Samskaras. Description of Consciousness (Knower).
Source: Bhagavad Gita, Chapter 13, Verse 1
Summary:
- CH13 title: Kṣetra-Kṣetranjña-Vibhāga-Yoga: Topic of Differentiation Between The Known and the Knower.
- Sri Krishna speak about:
- The entire Reality consisting of: Subject and the Object (kṣetrajña-kṣetra).
- Values required to know the reality with unmistakable clarity (jñāna).
- Truth to be known (jñeya).
- Lord’s relationship with His creative power (puruṣa-prakṛti).
- In V1, Krishna takes on the first two words: kṣetra-kṣetrajña (V1-6).
Bhagavad Gita, Chapter 13, Verse 1:
śrībhagavān uvāca
idam śarīram kaunteya kṣetram iti abhidhīyate ।
etat yaḥ vetti tam prāhuḥ kṣetrajñaḥ iti tat-vidaḥ ॥ 13-1
Lord Krishna said – Oh Arjuna! This body is known as kṣetraṁ (the field). (There is a conscious principle) which knows this (field). Wise men declare that (knower principle) to be ksetrajñā.
- Continuing VERSE 1 from last session…
-
KṢETRAM:
- Refers to anything known, right now.
- It refers to Body-Mind & Universe.
- In reference to Body-Mind, Universe.
- Kṣetram has 2 meanings…
- MEANING 1:
- That which undergoes unceasing transformation.
- We are using 5-kośa model to recognize what undergoes transformation. By knowing what transforms… then whatever is left, is kṣetrajña (Knower). Upādhi/Upahita.
- 1) Annamaya kośa (food layer):
- Body with mass & weight. Made out of food.
- Through which 5 organs of perception (situated in subtle-body) perceive through the physical instruments like (physical) eyes, ears.
- Through which 5 organs of action (situated in subtle-body) are capable of sending output to appropriate physical instruments like (physical) sex organ, hands, feet.
- 2) Prāṇmaya kośa (lifeforce layer):
- How to understand invisible prāṇa (Qi)? It’s an intelligence which maintains body functions. Gives body sentiency. Such as:
- Prāṇa: Automation of inhale/exhale.
- Apāna: Excretion.
- Samāna: Regulating digestion.
- Vyāna: Circulation.
- Udāna: Prāṇa of reversal. EG: Vomit/burping & reverses process of mind attaching to body at conception.
- How to understand invisible prāṇa (Qi)? It’s an intelligence which maintains body functions. Gives body sentiency. Such as:
- 3) Manomaya kośa (Mind layer)
- Produces emotions which correspond to thoughts. Emotions then manifest at level of brain-chemistry (annamaya kośa) through the limbic system (Hypothalamus, Hippocampus, Amygdala).
- It also gathers data from 5 senses and assembles it into 1-complete scene for processing by the Intellect.
- EG: Space shuttle launch.
- Sound waves are captured by delicate hair-like cells.
- Vibrations are converted to nerve impulses.
- Impulses are fed into the physical brain (annamaya kośa) which sends data to manomaya-kośa for interpretation.
- Seeing shape/color through eye.
- Smelling liquid hydrogen/oxygen fuel through nose.
- Feeling the sound-wave pulsations on the skin.
- Tasting the candy through tongue.
- Sound waves are captured by delicate hair-like cells.
- EG: Space shuttle launch.
- 4) Vijñānamaya kośa (Intellect layer):
- Takes data from manomaya and makes sense out of it through: (1) categorization (viveka), and (2) meaning/conclusion.
- What determines (1) HOW Intellect will categorize experience? and (2) WHAT meaning/conclusion it will make? Causal Body (kāraṇa śarīra).
- Intellect (buddhi) mechanism makes possible: problem solving, intuition, insights, discrimination, decision making.
- Inside buddhi, there’s another mechanism called: aham kāra
- aham kāra localizes/contains/isolates the experience to the total individual (all kośas).
- EG: If your buddhi concludes “Body is hungry”, do you start feeding another body?
- aham kāra localizes/contains/isolates the experience to the total individual (all kośas).
- Takes data from manomaya and makes sense out of it through: (1) categorization (viveka), and (2) meaning/conclusion.
- 5) Kāraṇa śarīra (Causal Body layer) (better in this context then ānandamaya-kośa)
- Why is it called “Casual Body”? Because it’s the CAUSE or SEED out of which former 4-layers are formed.
- Order from top-down:
- Causal Body dictates HOW & WHAT Intellect is to think/compute.
- Intellect dictates WHAT mind emotes.
- Mind dictates quality of prāṇa.
- Prāṇa dictates quality/quantity of chemical/hormones in physical body.
- It stores sañcita-karma. It preserves unexpressed EFFECTS, CAUSED by actions in ALL former lifetimes.
- Each life, portion of sañcita-karma is assigned to be experienced in this life. Assigned portion is called: prārabdha-karma.
- In Katha Upaniṣad, it states: At time of inception, each jīva is assigned specific number of breaths [for sake of completing the duration of prārabdha-karma].
- Can be extended via Yogic tantra EG: Siddha Tirumūlar wrote about in Tirumandiram.
- In Katha Upaniṣad, it states: At time of inception, each jīva is assigned specific number of breaths [for sake of completing the duration of prārabdha-karma].
- This prārabdha-karma manifests as saṃskāras (habits / impressions).
- These habits/impressions dictate WHAT & HOW the Intellect thinks.
- EG: If saṃskāra has orientation for music, then it will orient Intellect to think music-kindred thoughts.
- The thinking sculpts the jīva’s personality by teenage.
- Through jīva’s freewill, one can either submit to these saṃskāra-oriented-thinking-patterns OR change them.
- Each life, portion of sañcita-karma is assigned to be experienced in this life. Assigned portion is called: prārabdha-karma.
- Thus concludes MEANING 1 of kṣetram.
- MEANING 2:
- Kṣetram means agricultural land/field.
- What do we do on such a field? Plant seeds.
- Why plant seeds? So they can grow and produce fruits for consumption.
- Meaning field is the MEDIUM by which seeds can produce fruits.
- Similarly, kṣetram (body) is a MEDIUM through which the Causal Body (seed) reaps puṇya/pāpa.
- What’s the logic of rebirth?
- Human generally wants to live forever.
- Why? So I can continue enjoying fruits of my actions. In other words: To carry on reaping rewards of my endeavors.
- Because person doesn’t do action for action sake. But for immediate/future enjoyment sake.
- In short: I want a return on my investment.
- However body only lives 90+- years. So where will those remaining unmanifest rewards go?
- They can’t get destroyed because nothing can go out of existence, because there’s no two-existences.
- So only other option is: an appropriate body is produced to continue reaping rewards from previous life.
- They come in form of pleasant-unpleasant experiences (puṇya/pāpa karma).
- Why? So I can continue enjoying fruits of my actions. In other words: To carry on reaping rewards of my endeavors.
- Human generally wants to live forever.
- SUMMARY:
- Whatever is experienced in past, present, future… is kṣetram.
- Whatever is changing in quality, quantity in time (even dream time)… is kṣetram.
- Includes: body, mind, world. They are all made out of the same 5 elements (Verse 5), further made from 3 guṇas.
-
KṢETRANJÑA:
- Firstly what is kṣetram? Any experienced object. Anything which can be objectified.
- This presupposes a Reality in whose presence it objectifies the kṣetram. Meaning it’s not kṣetram.
- EG 1: Suppose you ask, “What is this Reality which is not kṣetram?”.
- Where did that question take place? In the kṣetram (5 kośa).
- Meaning one is already enjoying this Reality (objectified the 5 kośa, where that question was formed). Because we just said, in the presence of this Reality, the kṣetram is objectified.
- EG 2: Look at some object in the room. It’s seen because of the eye.
- Meaning, the fact that the eye can objectify, presupposes the existence of the eye.
- And even though the eye can’t perceive itself, the fact that THERE IS perception, proves the presence of the eye.
- Just as every photograph PROVES existence of the photographer, even though not perceived directly.
- In the same way, the perception of kṣetram (body-mind-world) presupposes a conscious being, who enjoys a Reality apart from kṣetram.
- EG 1: Suppose you ask, “What is this Reality which is not kṣetram?”.
- This illumining, aware-ing, conscious Reality (from standpoint of the body-mind) is called: kṣetrajña.
- What is description of kṣetrajña?
- Kṣetrajña is not a part, product or property of the body-mind.
- Kṣetrajña is an independent Reality which pervades the inert body-mind instrument, and thus makes it sentient.
- Kṣetrajña is not limited by boundaries of the body. Meaning it extends beyond the body.
- Although while body is alive, Kṣetrajña will feel (by the help of the body-mind instrument), as if the Kṣetrajña is contained within the body.
- Kṣetrajña continues to exist even after body perishes.
- Who says all this? tadvidaḥ, the jnanis/rishis who have already figured this out through the methodology that’s being expounded right now, and continues next session…
Keywords: karana sharira, ksetra, ksetrajna, kshetra, kshetrajna, pranamaya kosha, tirumular, upadhi, vijnanamaya kosha
—
Credit for help in Bhagavad Gita teaching given to Swami Dayananda (Arsha Vidya), Paramarthananda & Chinmaya Mission.
Recorded 14 April, 2021
Regarding ‘Ahamkara’, the ability to contain the experiences of individual’s body/ mind awareness.. Q: I assist people everyday with dementia who often have total confusion of spatial awareness, or inability to identity with their own physical urges, and other sensory confusion, eg. inability to differentiate between cold from hot sensation, or distinguish whether they are hungry or thirsty, ect. I often wonder with their ego diminishing, what happens to their ‘soul’ when they die? Do their samskaras become exhausted too before or when they pass away? Being with them for years and slowly seeing their personalities and egos fade, and also with them when they pass away, i have naturally always been very curious, trying to understand the answers to all this. Any feedback from you regarding this from the Vedic perspective would be greatly appreciated Andre. Im looking forward to more classes, thanks for including me.
============================
I often wonder with their ego diminishing, what happens to their ‘soul’ when they die?
============================
—————-
ANSWER 1: Liberated BEFORE Dementia/Alzheimer sets in…
—————-
If individual assimilated the final reality before Dementia/Alzheimer sets in, then upon death, no rebirth. Because mokṣa destroys the Causal Body immediately.
How so exactly? It doesn’t actually destroy (because nothing in universe can be destroyed since reality is non-dual).
Instead, identity is shifted FROM 5 kośas (including the Causal Body; the seed of ignorance which produces rebirth)… TO the presence that’s free of 5 kośas… which is Kṣetrajña.
Meaning even if the body-mind is subject to Dementia/Alzheimer in the future, then “I” still remain free of Dementia/Alzheimer. However “I” will certainly experience the suffering/frustration of the ailment.
—————-
ANSWER 2: Not Liberated and Dementia/Alzheimer sets in…
—————-
If individual HAS NOT assimilated the final reality and Dementia/Alzheimer sets in, then upon death, the same process happens as for any healthy individual carrying avidyā (ignorance of nature of “I AM”).
Upon death: The soul disassociates from the given body assigned to it in this life (for sake of exhausting prārabdha karma).
The word “soul” SPECIFICALLY means 3 components:
(1) Causal Body – which is sustained by beginningless ignorance
(2) Vijñānamaya kośa – Assessing/thinking/analyzing/problem solving mechanism.
(3) Manomaya kośa – Assembles world onto screen of mind, but also assembles the assessed data from Vijñānamaya kośa, then feeds it back to 5 organs of action (EG: through speech, feet, hands).
These 3 components will then borrow another portion from sañcita-karma, and be assigned a new prārabdha-karma.
According to WHAT prārabdha-karma (including the saṃskāras sculpted from previous life with Dementia) is assigned… will depend on what genetic makeup parents have.
Parents will then conceive an annamaya kośa (baby) which is 100% compatible with prārabdha-karma.
This process is the same for everyone, including you/me.
Even a deformed annamaya kośa (EG: baby dies due to complications) is due to prārabdha-karma.
============================
Do their samskaras become exhausted too before or when they pass away?
============================
It’s incorrect to say “samskaras become exhausted”. Rather “prārabdha karma gets exhausted”.
————–
Prārabdha karma:
————–
Means what turn of events the jīva (individual) will be confronted with.
EG: If baby is born in abusive family (no religion, little sense of morality)… that’s owing to Prārabdha karma assigned to the baby. Meaning the jīva in previous life lived a questionable life… thus receives corresponding next life.
In short: Jiva continues reaping what it’s sown in previous life.
————–
Saṃskārās (habits):
————–
These are habits that carry over from previous life. They never get exhausted. Rather, they are in constant flux.
EG: Sometimes we come with habit of empathy (habit to be nurturing to others). But friends tell us, “Don’t be so naive!”. Because we respect our friends, the person then adopts a more selfish approach.
Thus the empathy-saṃskāra has been altered into less-empathetic-saṃkāra in this life.
This is why saṃsāra is called: A life of becoming. Always becoming ____. And mokṣa is freedom from saṃsāra.
In short: Person’s behavior/personality today is result of saṃskāras (habits) of the past. The saṃskāras NEVER get exhausted because they are result of our actions. And when is person NOT doing? Never.
————–
Process of Rebirth in Order:
————–
1) As long as I remain a doer, I continue creating/modifying saṃskāras (habits).
2) Habits are cause of action which compel me to do.
3) To be a doer, is to produce consequences (pleasant/unpleasant).
4) To produce consequences is to experience them.
5) To experience them is to live one more day. If body dies, it gets reborn to continue experiencing/reaping what it’s sown from the past.
Fabulous explanation, thank you so much for your time to answer. I have been wondering about this for years and it brings me clarity and some peace 🙏